The Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference has released its 2023-24 all-conference teams for Men's Soccer. St. Thomas has a pair of first-team selections in Daniel Castro and Taty Aleman, both receiving first-team all-SCAC honors for the second time in as many seasons.

Castro tallied 11 goals and 28 points across 14 games for the Celts this season, both ranking third in the SCAC. His 11 goals included a pair of game-winners, and he also received Offensive Player of the Week honors earlier this season.

Aleman, also being highlighted on the SCAC's first team for a second consecutive season, posted an outstanding year, leading the conference in goals (17), points (37), and game-winners (5). The exclamation point of his season was an explosion against Centenary on October 20, when he recorded a UST single-game record five goals in an 8-1 victory. In addition to his big numbers on the year, Aleman received Offensive Player of the Week honors twice in leading the Celts this season.

The honorable mentions included Ian Alvarez, Angel Ramirez, Diego Lazo, Dany Ramirez, and Rodrigo Lazo. Alvarez posted 8 assists to lead the conference, showcasing solid all-around play for the Celts. Angel Ramirez and Diego Lazo were stalwarts defensively for the Celts all season, helping lead a unit that surrendered less than a goal per game for the season. Rodrigo Lazo appeared in 9 games for the Celts, contributing to 3 shutouts and posting overall strong play. Dany Ramirez recorded a solid all-around line for the season, putting up 3 goals, 5 assists, and 11 points in his 12 games played.

Freshman Daniel Flores also received honors for his performance this season, being named to the all-freshman team for the conference. Flores was one of only four Celts to play in all 16 matches this season, posting 3 goals, 1 assist, and 7 points of his own along the way.